Leave Room for an Honest Question

John 9:1–3 - As he passed by, he saw a man blind from birth. And his disciples asked him, “Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?” Jesus answered, “It was not that this man sinned, or his parents, but that the works of God might be displayed in him.

Read the account: John 9:1–7, 24–38.

Someone tells you something painful that they’re experiencing, and your mind begins searching for an explanation. Maybe this happened because they needed to slow down. Maybe God is preparing them for something. Maybe a different decision would have prevented it. You want to help, but before long, you’re trying to explain something you barely understand. The disciples do something similar when they encounter a man blind from birth. They ask Jesus whose sin caused his condition: his own or his parents’. Their question already contains a conclusion.

Read John 9:1–7. Notice the explanation the disciples propose, the answer Jesus gives, and the action that follows.

Jesus rejects their proposed connection between this man’s blindness and a particular person’s sin. He directs attention to God’s work and heals him. We need to be careful here. Jesus’ explanation of this encounter doesn’t authorize us to announce the specific reason behind every illness or disability. Reading carefully includes recognizing what a passage does, and does not, tell us.

Continue with verses 24–38. Follow the man’s responses as people question him.

Notice how he differentiates between what he knows from what he doesn’t know. He can’t answer every claim being made about Jesus, but he can absolutely testify to the change he has experienced. As the questioning continues, he reasons some more about Jesus. Later, Jesus finds the man and reveals His identity more fully, and the man responds with faith and worship. His understanding develops through the account. John lets us watch a man learning who Jesus is.

What does this teach us about ourselves? We can admit uncertainty without treating every truth as uncertain. You might not know why someone’s treatment failed. You might not know why a marriage ended despite years of prayer. But you can refuse an invented explanation while speaking clearly about the Savior revealed in Scripture. How Jesus entered human suffering and bore our sins at the cross and rose bodily from the grave. How His victory grounds our hope that suffering and death won’t have the final word.

That is great news, even when we can’t explain someone’s present circumstances. We don’t have to defend God with explanations He never gave. We can listen, remain present, and point toward what He has made known in His Son. Sometimes the most faithful sentence begins, “I don’t know why.” It can be followed by, “But I would be glad to walk through this with you.”

A tool to keep: Separate what the passage states from what you assume. Write down unanswered questions as questions.

Head: Careful observation helps us be clear about what God has revealed and humble about what He hasn’t.

Heart: When someone is suffering, do I feel pressure to explain what I might not completely understand?

Hands: Write one fact John 9 explicitly states and one question it leaves unanswered. Leave the question open while thanking God for what’s clear.

Prayer: “Lord Jesus, thank You for making Yourself known to people who still have questions. Help me speak clearly about Your saving work and humbly about what I don’t understand. Make me a patient, truthful companion to someone who is hurting. Amen.”

-PK

Previous
Previous

When the Words Become Clear

Next
Next

What Comes After Stopping?